Judith Sheindlin—better known as TV’s fearsome Judge Judy—has listed her Manhattan penthouse duplex for sale.
Known for her no-nonsense approach in the courtroom, Judge Judy brings that same precision and elegance to her luxurious NYC penthouse, now available for $9.5 million.
The property, located at the prestigious 14 Sutton Place South, is a testament to sophisticated urban living, and its sale marks a significant transition for the beloved television judge and her husband Jerry.
“Time to Simplify”
“We’ve enjoyed this jewel of an apartment. Time to simplify,” says Judy, explaining the decision behind listing their 14 Sutton Place South pad.
The penthouse, a marvel of prewar architecture and modern comfort, served as their pied-à-terre since they purchased it in 2013.
Now, as they look to simplify their lives, they leave behind a property that combines opulence with homey warmth, perfectly suited for Manhattan’s elite.
Inside Judge Judy’s NYC Penthouse
The penthouse itself is a masterpiece within a prewar co-op designed by renowned architect Rosario Candela in 1929.
Overlooking the East River, the building includes 92 units, each exuding classic New York charm.
Judge Judy’s penthouse is thoughtfully restored, maintaining many original touches while integrating modern amenities.
It boasts four bedrooms, four bathrooms, two powder rooms, two working fireplaces, and an airy chef’s kitchen with professional-grade appliances, making it both a functional and luxurious living space.
Wood-Paneled Library and Elegant Entertaining Spaces
One of the most enticing features of the penthouse is the wood-paneled private library.
Ideal for quiet reflection or an intimate gathering, this space invites residents to enjoy a classic novel by the fireplace with a glass of wine.
The home is equally equipped for entertaining, featuring a formal red-walled dining room with floor-to-ceiling French casement doors and a spacious living room with a second wood-burning fireplace.
These areas seamlessly extend to the wraparound terrace, offering guests breathtaking views of the East River and Roosevelt Island tram.
The Wraparound Terrace
The wraparound terrace is a standout feature of this luxurious property, accessible from the living room, dining room, and library.
It includes two separate alfresco dining areas, a lounge, and is adorned with lush, mature plantings, creating a serene escape in the heart of the city.
The terrace provides a perfect setting for hosting friends or simply enjoying a quiet moment amidst the urban landscape, reaffirming the penthouse’s status as an urban sanctuary.
Dramatic Entrance and Elegant Staircase
Judge Judy’s penthouse also boasts a dramatic 29-foot entrance gallery and a curved staircase, echoing the judge’s commanding presence in the courtroom.
This grand entrance sets the tone for the elegant interiors that await.
The staircase leads to the upper level where the four bedrooms are located, each exuding comfort and style.
Three of these bedrooms have en suite marble bathrooms, offering a private retreat for residents and guests alike.
Luxurious Upstairs Bedrooms
The primary bedroom is a luxurious haven featuring a sitting area, built-in storage, and a large closet, ensuring ample space for relaxation and organization.
The en suite marbled bathroom adds a touch of opulence, providing a spa-like experience within the home.
The thoughtful design and high-quality finishes throughout the penthouse reflect Judge Judy’s discerning taste and attention to detail.
Summary
Judge Judy’s famous saying, “Beauty fades, dumb is forever,” captures her sharp wit and pragmatic outlook on life.
However, her penthouse at 14 Sutton Place South is a testament to enduring beauty and timeless elegance, ensuring its appeal won’t be fading anytime soon.
As she moves on to the next chapter, the opportunity to own a piece of her sophisticated lifestyle awaits a discerning buyer.
Listed By: Tom Postilio and Mickey Conlon
For removal, credit or copyright issues please check our disclaimer page for more information.
