Location: Wainscott, NY
Size: 25 acres
Price: $67.5 Million
Specs: 25,000 sq ft
Year: 2000
Rooms: 8 beds, 14 baths
Tucked away at the end of a private, gated road in Wainscott, New York, lies one of the most spectacular and exclusive properties on the East Coast—Burnt Point, located at 38 Mathews Road.
Priced at $67,500,000, this monumental estate sprawls across approximately 25 acres of pristine peninsula land on the shores of Georgica Pond.
With over 2,000 feet of direct water frontage, panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean, and seamless indoor-outdoor living across an astonishing 25,000 square feet, this home is more than a luxurious retreat—it is a landmark in Hamptons real estate.
A Peninsula of Tranquility and Prestige
The estate sits like a crown jewel on its very own peninsula—bordered by Georgica Pond on three sides and offering uninterrupted views that sweep across the water to the horizon.
Manicured lawns stretch lazily down to the pond’s edge, and the property’s scale ensures complete seclusion from neighboring estates.
Just minutes from the elite attractions of East Hampton Village and ocean beaches, yet cloaked in the peaceful hush of waterfront wilderness, Burnt Point delivers the best of both worlds—undisturbed serenity and immediate access to the Hamptons’ cultural, culinary, and recreational offerings.
Artisanal Interiors and World-Class Craftsmanship
Step inside and discover a masterpiece of architecture and interior design.
The interiors were originally curated by Brian O’Keefe and designer Marjorie Shushan, then given a modern reimagination by renowned designer Michael Smith, famed for his work in the Obama White House.
The result is a seamless blend of traditional craftsmanship and contemporary taste.
The estate’s design incorporates 200-year-old antique oak floors, arched doorways, and six custom-crafted stone fireplaces.
The finishes are handcrafted, and no two rooms are alike—each space carries its own identity while contributing to a harmonious whole.
Nearly every room is graced with floor-to-ceiling windows or French doors, framing the estate’s panoramic water views like living artwork.
Thoughtful Layout and Livable Elegance
Despite its remarkable scale and luxury, the home was designed to be fully livable and intuitive.
The five-bedroom main residence includes a spacious and elegantly appointed primary suite with breathtaking views, a spa-like bathroom, and walk-in wardrobes.
Every bedroom in the main home includes en suite baths and bespoke detailing, ensuring guests or family members enjoy their own private haven.
A three-bedroom guest wing offers complete independence for long-term guests, staff, or extended family.
Connected by a Cotswold stone breezeway, the guest wing includes its own kitchen and living areas.
The flow between the primary and guest quarters provides privacy while maintaining a unified architectural language.
In total, the home features ten full bathrooms and four half baths, as well as two commercial-grade elevators servicing all floors.
Multiple sitting rooms, a formal dining room, and open-concept living areas offer a mix of elegance and comfort.
A library, offices, and family rooms are designed for everyday use, offering flexible and luxurious spaces for work and leisure alike.
An Entertainer’s Dream with Endless Amenities
While the interiors are breathtaking, the outdoor spaces are equally captivating.
Anchored by a stunning waterside infinity-edge pool with a waterfall spa, the backyard delivers the feel of a five-star resort.
The limestone-floored screened-in outdoor dining room offers shaded luxury in the warmer months, complete with a built-in barbecue and seating for large gatherings.
The estate’s sunken Har-Tru tennis court includes a viewing pavilion and is perfect for both casual games and competitive matches.
Terraces throughout the property are constructed from European sandstone and Cotswold stone, lending a refined rusticity that matches the natural surroundings.
A professional greenhouse stands ready for gardening enthusiasts or professionals alike.
The expansive lawns, mature plantings, and curated gardens are as much a part of the luxury experience as the architecture itself.
Throughout the property, underground tunnels house mechanical systems, ensuring both convenience and minimal visual disruption to the estate’s stunning design.
Parking and storage are no afterthought. The estate includes multiple garages that can accommodate up to 10 vehicles, with direct access to the home and service areas.
The driveway is wide and circular, allowing ease of movement for guests and staff alike.
Summary
Whether as a year-round home, summer compound, or multigenerational retreat, Burnt Point stands in a class of its own in the Hamptons real estate landscape.
Its historical recognition, architectural pedigree, and irreplaceable location make it a truly once-in-a-lifetime acquisition.
Listing by: Compass 631-324-1700, Ed Petrie – Associate Real Estate Broker
For removal, credit or copyright issues please check our disclaimer page for more information.
